Pirates of the Caribbean: At Wit's End
I find it very thoughtful of the people at Disney to ask
film critics not to reveal the plot of “Pirates of the Caribbean:
At World’s End.” Thoughtful because I doubt if a single critic, myself
included, has any idea what the plot is, not just of this installment but the
previous two, and their request gives us an excuse not to have to try to
explain it. In fact, I suspect that not even the people at Disney or the
filmmakers themselves could summarize the story. Instead of a narrative in the
classical sense it is an arbitrary series of crises, of tension and release, of
inconsequential entanglement and resolution that is ultimately static, circular
and repetitive, a vastly elaborated variation on the basic structure it is
derived from, the amusement park ride. The film’s genius is not so much in the
narrative, but in the individual episodes, the baroque sight gags, the effects
and the visual tropes along the way, worthy of silent comedy classics or
surrealist reveries, but if word leaked out about that, “Pirates of the Caribbean” might reach the franchise’s end.