The Phoenix Network:
The Phoenix
Boston
|
Portland
|
Providence
Stuff@Night
WFNX
Live Radio
|
On Demand
Adult
About
|
Advertise
Moonsigns
|
Band Guide
|
Blogs
|
In Pictures
Music
CD Reviews
|
Classical
|
Download
|
Live Reviews
|
Music Features
|
New England Music News
--> -->
See all in CD Reviews
The Color Fred
CD Reviews
The Heartless Bastards
All This Time | Fat Possum
By
DAVID BOFFA
|
January 22, 2007
THE HEARTLESS BASTARDS, ALL THIS TIME
" alt="photo of 'THE HEARTLESS BASTARDS, ALL THIS TIME'">
2.5
Stars
The Heartless Bastards are a Dayton trio fronted by Erika Wennerstrom, an extremely shy woman with the voice of a blues crooner. Shortly after Patrick Carney of the Black Keys discovered them in an empty Akron bar, they released
Stairs and Elevators
to mixed reviews. The main knock: a “no frills” songwriting approach that lacked hooks. A few awkward attempts at a hit do appear on
All This Time
— “Into the Open” includes a forced piano theme and the title track is choked with synthesizers and cheesy love-song lyrics. But the downtrodden “Blue Day” and the instrumentally spare “Came a Long Way” have Wennerstrom in her comfort zone, singing about soul searching in guttural roars over three-chord guitar jams. So this sophomore effort isn’t simply a failed sellout. What else would you expect from a band who practice in their bassist’s janitorial-supply warehouse?
Related
:
Beyond the White Stripes
Alison Krauss and Robert Plant lead an Americana resurgence
John Doe
A Year in the Wilderness | Yep Roc
Clearly Canadian
New mpfrees from a not-so-secret source
More
Beyond the White Stripes
Alison Krauss and Robert Plant lead an Americana resurgence
John Doe
A Year in the Wilderness | Yep Roc
Clearly Canadian
New mpfrees from a not-so-secret source
None more black
Droning on with Austin's Black Angels
No clock ticking
Jay Reatard channels his inner problem child
Chairmen of the boards
Our critics pick the 14 producers with the fattest, meanest beats
Indie gets the blues
The Gossip, the Black Keys, and the Kills
Less
Topics
:
CD Reviews
,
Patrick Carney
,
The Black Keys
Share
:
Rss
Email
Print
Comments
Add a Comment
Today's Event Picks
[ART]
REMEMBER: MEDICINE WHEEL
Plus 4 more >>
ARTICLES BY DAVID BOFFA
MONSTER MOSH
| November 07, 2008
Bane at ICC, October 31, 2008
RED SPAROWES
| September 02, 2008
Aphorisms | Sargent House
HIP-HOP THE HARD WAY
| September 02, 2008
The Press Project at Bill's Bar, August 29, 2008
CONOR OBERST
| August 26, 2008
Conor Oberst | Merge
NOISE IN THE HOOD
| July 07, 2008
Big Digits and Chinese Stars at Middle East Upstairs, July 5, 2008
See all articles by:
DAVID BOFFA
MOST POPULAR
Most Viewed
Most Emailed
VANISHING BOSTON
A field guide to Boston's 'lasting' treasures — to be enjoyed before they're razed in favor of chain stores
HOORAY FOR SPACE!
Big Fat Whale
MEDICINE MEN
Two Boston poets use their art for the good of the tribe
SCOTT WEILAND | “HAPPY” IN GALOSHES
Softdrive/New West (2008)
SLIDESHOW: VANISHING BOSTON
Classic locations threatened
MEDICINE MEN
Two Boston poets use their art for the good of the tribe
PRIMORDIAL STAGES
Boston's open mics: Launch pads or crash sites?
GONGS WITH ROBOT
Gamelan Galak Tika does crossover
WINSOR DIM SUM CAFÉ
Dim sum all day and night
VANISHING BOSTON
A field guide to Boston's 'lasting' treasures — to be enjoyed before they're razed in favor of chain stores
HOT TOPICS
Boston Symphony Orchestra
,
Kim Deal
,
Radiohead
,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
,
Harvard University
,
Kurt Weill
,
James Levine
,
James Robinson
,
John Harbison
,
Brian Eno
More Topics
. . .
LATEST SLIDESHOWS
Photos: Peter Simon's new book
Slideshow: Vanishing Boston
All Slideshows
Explore your Fantasies
Featured Articles in Books
:
Interview: John Hodgman
Never Say Smile
Excerpt: The School on Heart's Content Road
Here comes the sun
Interview: Art Spiegelman
Monday, December 01, 2008
|
Sign In
|
Register
thePhoenix.com:
Home
Listings
Editor's Picks
News
Music
Film + TV
Food + Drink
Life
Arts
Rec Room
Video
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Boston Phoenix
Portland Phoenix
Providence Phoenix
StuffAtNight
People2People
MassWeb Printing
G8Wave
About Us
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Work For Us
Sitemap
RSS
Mobile
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
Copyright © 2008 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group